Miss Stutzman moved to Cincinnati in 2024 from Naples, Florida, after graduating from Ave Maria University. She has a degree in health science as well as a minor in biology and theology. She attended both a classical liberal arts high school and university, which motivated her to pursue a career teaching at a classical school. Miss Stutzman previously worked as an assistant preschool teacher at a private school in Cincinnati. During her free time, she enjoys traveling, reading, gardening, and cooking.